Ceci n'est pas un blog
Archive for February, 2012
Hymns of hope (3) It is well with my soul
Feb 20th
Horatio Spafford's moving hymn, When peace, like a river, is somewhat marred by a line in a verse that apparently was not in the original version or even the original (?) published version:
But, Lord, ’tis for Thee, for Thy coming we wait,
The sky, not the grave, is our goal;
Oh, trump of the angel! Oh, voice of the Lord!
Blessed hope, blessed rest of my soul!
(I'd be interested to know where that verse came from: leave a comment below if you know.)
I've taken to singing "The earth, not the grave is our goal", because the Christian hope is ultimately not to stay in heaven (the sky?) for ever, but for the Lord to return, for the dead to be restored to bodily life, and for the meek to inherit... the sky?
But perhaps better would be to miss out that verse altogether, and to stick with Spafford's final verse, which is much richer:
And Lord, haste the day when my faith shall be sight,
The clouds be rolled back as a scroll;
The trump shall resound, and the Lord shall descend,
Even so, it is well with my soul.
God the law-giver and his creation
Feb 17th
Chapter 2 of Creation Regained covers the first theme of the creation-fall-redemption triad: creation. It's quite a lengthy chapter, so I'll cover it in two parts.
We might talk about "the story of creation" (in the beginning) and "the beauty of creation" (now), but in either case, Christians believe that God is intimately involved. Searching for a word to describe "the totality of God's ordaining acts toward the cosmos" (p.15), Wolters chooses to go with the word law. (I suppose we could also think of God's decrees.) God institutes laws of nature, but also gives laws for culture and society: norms.
Just as a human sovereign does certain things himself, but gives orders to his subordinates for other things, so with God himself. He put the planets in their orbits, makes the seasons come and go at the proper time, makes seeds grow and animals reproduce, but entrusts to mankind the tasks of making tools, doing justice, producing art, and pursuing scholarship. In other words, God's rule of law is immediate in the nonhuman realm but mediate in culture and society. In the human realm men and women become coworkers with God; as creatures made in God's image they too have a kind of lordship over the earth, are God's viceroys in creation (p.16).
In addition to that distinction between laws of nature and norms, we can distinguish between these general laws, and God's particular laws, for specific events to take place, or for specific people to do specific things.
In speaking of "creation" as "the correlation of the sovereign activity of the Creator and the created order" (p.14), the term becomes much broader in scope that what we usually take it to mean.
Usually when we speak of creation we have in mind the realities investigated by the natural sciences—the structure of the atom, the movements of the solar system, the life cycle of a plant, the building instinct of a beaver (p.24).
But, with the broader definition,
We will not make such a distinction if we understand creation in terms of a law-subject correlation. God's ordinances also extend to the structures of society, to the world of art, to business and commerce. Human civilization is normed throughout. Everywhere we discover limits and proprieties, standards and criteria: in every field of human affairs there are right and wrong ways of doing things. There is nothing in human life that does not belong to the created order (p.25).
So when (using God's general revelation and our wisdom) we figure out how best to run a business, we are uncovering something about God's creation, just as much as when we figure out how stars make their light.
Hymns of hope (2) There is a day
Feb 16th
Another Christian song that expresses the Christian hope well is one of my favourites, There is a day, by Nathan Fellingham (2001) of Phatfish. Helpfully, it doesn't make us look forward to escaping this creation and going somewhere else, but the first lines express the Christian hope for the creation itself:
There is a day that all creation's waiting for,
A day of freedom and liberation for the earth.
What follows is simply saturated with Scripture. Here's the chorus:
We will meet Him in the air,
And then we will be like Him,
For we will see Him as He is, oh yeah!
Then all hurt and pain will cease,
And we'll be with Him forever,
And in His glory we will live,
Oh yeah, oh yeah!
The idea of meeting the Lord in the air as he descends from heaven to earth at his parousia (royal visit) is helpfully explained by Tom Wright:
[T]heir 'meeting' with the Lord doesn't mean they will then be staying in mid-air with him. They are like Roman citizens in a colony, going out to meet the emperor when he pays them a state visit, and then accompanying him back to the city itself (Paul for Everyone: Galatians and Thessalonians, 125).
It gives a renewed perspective on all that I do on earth to think that Jesus will one day be paying a royal visit, not to take me away, but to put everything right, and to stay here for ever. "Oh yeah" indeed!
Hymns of hope (1) King of the ages
Feb 13th
This is part 1 of a series looking at the theme of hope in Christian hymns and songs. (I hope the series will have more than one part, but don't assume I have a coherent plan!)
What do Christians hope (expect) to happen in the future?
For Christians whose view of the future is shaped by the Christian Scriptures, their ultimate hope is "the resurrection of the dead, and the life of the [age] to come" (Nicene Creed), or "the resurrection of the body, and the life everlasting" (Apostles' Creed). The hope is that Jesus will come back to this earth, and that he will stay here and put everything right, in the "regeneration" (Mt 19:28), when all things will be restored (Acts 3:21) and made new (Rev 21:5), and when "the creation itself will be set free" (Rom 8:21, ESV).
But often in Christian hymns and songs we sing of our hope in totally un-Christian terms, singing about escaping this world and going to heaven for ever, or about Jesus coming back in order to take us away, as though God's plan for the future is that the creation itself will be thrown away, rather than set free. And this really matters. If we want to live worthwhile lives, we need to know what will happen to our works when Jesus returns. If the only thing that will survive the purifying fires of judgement is human souls, then everything is ultimately a pointless waste of time, except evangelism. But if when Jesus returns he will take everything—not only renewed human beings, but also societal structures, agriculture, business, scientific knowledge, technology, poetry, music, or whatever—and incorporate the good aspects of those cultural riches into the renewed creation, then in everything we do we can truly "abound[...] in the work of the Lord, knowing that in the Lord [our] labour is not in vain" (1Cor 15:58, ESV).
Anyway, here's an example of a hymn that, I think, expresses the Christian hope well. It's King of the ages by Stuart Townend and Keith Getty (2002), the final verse in particular. It doesn't say everything, but it does at least focus our attention on the future coming of Christ, helping us to "set [our] hope fully on the grace that will be brought to [us] at the revelation of Jesus Christ" (1Pet 1:13, ESV):
The day will come when You appear,
And every eye shall see You.
Then we shall rise with hearts ablaze,
With a song we will sing forever.
It's got a good solid tune too.
The gospel in the gospels?
Feb 10th
The gospel: Jesus came to earth to die and to rise again.
But what about all the stuff Jesus did before he died, which the four gospels tell us about? Is that part of the gospel, or just the backdrop for the real gospel?
According to N.T. Wright, in his recent talk on How God Became King: Why We've All Misunderstood the Gospels, the gospels are entirely about the gospel. They present us with a unified story of Jesus' ministry, death and resurrection. It is the story of How God became King, a story with four strands...
- The story of Jesus as the story of Israel. God called Israel to be his means of rescue, and the climax is reached as Israel's Messiah becomes the world's King [from 19:40].
- The story of Jesus as the story of Israel's God, the self-giving, covenant-keeping Creator [from 26:40].
- The story of Jesus as the story of how the church was founded, as part of God's plan, as King, to renew the world through his renewed, cross-bearing people [from 34:30].
- The story of Jesus as the story of how Israel's God defeated the powers of the world, and the dark power that stands behind them all. Jesus is enthroned, and Caesar and all other powers (earthly and demonic) are dethroned [from 39:20].
N.T. Wright - January Series 2012 from Calvin College on Vimeo.
Hat tip: Steve Bishop.
WALL-E (2008)
Feb 8th
We watched WALL-E (2008) last night.
It's a great story. It's about planet earth, a planet that was supposed to be beautiful—in its landscapes, in the plants and animals it supported, and in the human civilisation that developed on it. But this planet had been left desolate, reduced to a heap of trash by the greed, futility and disconnectedness of the people who inhabited it. But it's also a story of hope. A love story develops between the central character, WALL-E, and another robot. And so powerful is this love story that it brings in its wake not only the re-humanising of humanity, but ultimately the renewal of the whole planet.
And it's a whole lot of fun too.
But what I like most about this story, as about any story, is the resonances it has with a far greater story...

I live in York and I'm a research fellow in